July 8, 2024

The Youngstown Cookie Table

The Youngstown area is filled with rich-history, family-ties, and traditions – we love our traditions. If you’ve ever been to a wedding in the Youngstown, Ohio area you’re probably aware of the locally famous tradition of the Cookie Table. As soon as guests arrive at the wedding reception, the first thing their hungry eyes draw to are the hundreds of cookies laid out along several tables in the reception area.

Menning Photographic

Youngstown Cookie Table

The idea of a cookie table may be unfamiliar to many, but to Youngstown- it is a topic of conversation and a visual focal point at weddings. This tradition includes the display of hundreds of cookies on a long table with large dishes and stands, in order to supplement other offered desserts like cake. 

Immigrants who settled in Youngstown brought many wonderful food and baking traditions. During the Great Depression, wedding cakes were often too expensive, so family and friends would contribute an impressive array of cookies for wedding receptions.

Menning Photographic

Cookie Varieties

Cookie tables can vary, but some cookie varieties are staples at every memorable display. Check out the links to recipes below to ensure that your cookie table is complete.


These cookies vary from family to family, and you may have family recipes to follow, but the above are key players to many Youngstown cookie tables.

Menning Photographic

Most cookie tables feature homemade cookies, crafted with love and attention to detail. Here are some tips to make the process easier and more manageable:

  1. Bake and Freeze: Prepare cookies a few weeks ahead and freeze them to avoid last-minute stress.
  2. Share the Workload: Enlist multiple bakers to share the workload and costs. This can also add a delightful variety of cookies.
  3. Order Cookies: For convenience, consider ordering cookies from a bakery. Coordinate delivery details well in advance.
  4. Designate a “cookie-person”: This persons responsibility is to gather the cookies from the bakery or family and deliver them to the venue


At DeYor Performing Arts Center in Youngstown, we provide proper storage conditions, tables, linens, and more – to make your Youngstown Cookie Table a huge success. Make sure to be detailed, overly considerate of guest counts, and always do what you can to be prepared. The Youngstown Cookie Table stands firm as a symbol to our region, for its deep-rooted commitment to family and tradition.

Wedding Inquiry Form

Are you interested in DeYor for your wedding day? Please complete our Wedding Inquiry Form, one of our Event Coordinators will reach out to you as soon as possible.